Login
Keystone Policy Center and FutureEd Release New Report on Modernizing School Accountability
In the evolving landscape of public education, how we define and measure school success matters more than ever. For decades, school performance systems in the United States have centered largely on standardized test scores—especially in math and reading. But this narrow approach has significant limitations, both in what it tells us and in how it shapes educational outcomes.
That’s why Keystone Policy Center partnered with FutureEd on a groundbreaking new report: Quality Check: The New, Best Way to Measure School Performance. This report offers a comprehensive rethinking of school accountability, proposing a more balanced and sophisticated system for evaluating how schools are serving their students.
Why Change Is Needed
The current model of test-based accountability emerged from well-intentioned reforms over the past two decades, such as No Child Left Behind (NCLB) and the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA). While these laws pushed for greater transparency and equity, they also placed outsized weight on standardized assessments—often reducing school quality to a single summative score.
This approach fails to capture the complex, multidimensional nature of learning environments. It has led to unintended consequences, including:
- A narrowed curriculum that sidelines subjects like science, social studies, and the arts.
- Overemphasis on test preparation.
- A lack of actionable information for school improvement.
- Disincentives for collaboration and innovation.
What a Better System Looks Like
Quality Check identifies and explores promising alternatives that are already taking root in school districts and states across the country. It draws on extensive research, real-world examples, and stakeholder input to recommend a more comprehensive performance measurement framework.
Key Elements of the New Framework
Multiple Measures of Success
Performance should reflect more than proficiency on standardized tests. The report advocates for systems that incorporate:
- Student growth over time
- School climate and culture
- Chronic absenteeism
- Access to advanced coursework
- Postsecondary readiness
- Access to resources
Disaggregated Data
Measuring subgroup performance is critical to identifying and addressing opportunity gaps. Quality Check underscores the need for disaggregated metrics that illuminate disparities across race, income, language, and ability.
Local and Contextualized Insights
School quality is experienced at the local level, and communities deserve data that reflects their realities. The report encourages systems that empower educators and families with clear, relevant, and actionable information—not just accountability labels.
Transparency with Purpose
Accountability systems must not only identify low-performing schools—they must also support improvement. That means investing in tools and technical assistance that help schools respond to performance data in meaningful ways.
Real-World Momentum
Several states are already moving in this direction. The report highlights examples from places like:
- California, which has developed a dashboard system including chronic absenteeism, graduation rates, and college/career readiness.
- Illinois, where school climate surveys are incorporated into annual ratings.
- Massachusetts, which emphasizes student growth percentiles alongside achievement.
These efforts show that shifting away from test-only measures is not only possible—it’s already underway.
Shelby Coffey III is a distinguished journalist, media executive, and thought leader whose career has helped shape the landscape of American news and public discourse. Over several decades, Coffey has held some of the most influential roles in journalism, including serving as editor of the Los Angeles Times, executive vice president of ABC News, and deputy managing editor of The Washington Post. His editorial leadership extended to key roles as president of CNN Financial News, editor of the Dallas Times Herald, and U.S. News & World Report.
Effective March 1, 2025, Thomas J. Vilsack, former United States Secretary of Agriculture and Governor of Iowa, became the first Chief Executive Officer for the World Food Prize Foundation. In this new role, Governor Vilsack is focusing on expanding the Foundation’s global network, and will further position the Foundation as a leader in addressing global food and nutrition insecurity, continuing his lifetime of public service.
Jerry Steiner has spent 40 years involved in agriculture following growing up on a Wisconsin dairy farm. He began his career with Monsanto, in multiple business leadership roles. From 2003-2013 he served as a member of the Executive team, as the company’s Executive Vice President of Sustainability and Corporate Affairs. He led the company’s global Government, Public and Industry Affairs teams across the 70 countries where Monsanto conducts business. This experience got Jerry connected to the Keystones centers work in agriculture. Key among his responsibilities were shaping the company’s public policy and building partnerships aimed at helping farmers around the world produce more food, while conserving valuable resources like water and energy. Two unique partnership that developed under his leadership were drought tolerant corn with 5 African countries, CIMMYT and the Gates foundation, and a building a sustainable business model in Brazil with the value chain leading to significant multi-company investment and soybean varieties that can protected themselves.
Jennifer Morris is the Chief Executive Officer of The Nature Conservancy, leading a team of nearly 6,000 staff working in more than 80 countries and territories tackling the dual crises of the 
Congressman Joe Neguse represents Colorado’s 2nd District in the U.S. House of Representatives. He was elected to his first term in November 2018, becoming the first Black Member of Congress in Colorado history. In December 2022, Rep. Neguse was elected by his colleagues to serve as Chair of the Democratic Policy and Communications Committee (DPCC), becoming the first Coloradan to serve in a senior elected leadership role in the House in over 85 years. He serves on the Natural Resources and Judiciary Committees, and was also appointed by House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries to serve as one of four Democrats on the prestigious Rules Committee. Rep. Neguse serves as Ranking Member on the House Subcommittee on Federal Lands, which he previously Chaired in the 117th Congress.
Llewellyn King was born in Southern Rhodesia, now Zimbabwe. He went into journalism as soon as he turned 16, stringing for Time magazine and United Press in Africa.
Steven Williams is the Chief Executive Officer of PepsiCo North America, overseeing a more than $48 billion business that spans PepsiCo’s Foods and Beverage operating units. His leadership encompasses more than 125,000 associates and over 900 locations across the U.S. and Canada. Steven joined PepsiCo in 2001 as part of PepsiCo’s acquisition of the Quaker Oats Company, which he joined in 1997, and has held leadership positions of increased responsibility since.